Sunday, August 28, 2016

Blog Post 1

Reacting to Barzun, "Prime difficulty: What is my subject?"

This was a great reading to go through because it sheds light on key aspects of research, and the points brought up are very important yet easily overlooked or not thought of at all when it comes to research.  The difference between a notion and a subject was excellent because I have struggled with that before.  My sophomore year I did a research project based on the pipe organ, entitled "History of the Pipe Organ, 1400-1600" I believe.  I ran into the same problem that the author describes.  There was so much information that surfaced during my time engrossed in the archives and I tried to include as much of it as possible but I believe it ended up creating a disorganized mess that left many questions unanswered.  Had I focused on a more select subject, such as changes in the acoustics of the pipes, how the use of the organ changed, production of the organ, or perhaps how the organ adapted to an increasingly secular world, I would have had an easier time and had a better final result as well.  Even those subjects can branch off into several other subjects as well.
I think it's an interesting idea that the longer your title is the narrower your subject becomes.  It's an inverted relationship that is crucial to formulating a complete and well organized statement about your subject.  The reading also had a touch of humor and used excellent and approachable language so that I was engrossed with the variable context.
My main take away from this reading was comparing it to education.  Research isn't that different at all from teaching.  You have to fully understand and master a subject before sharing it with your readers/classroom.  You can't effectively answer a question or teach a lesson if you don't know the subject material.

Reacting to Knott, "Writing an Annotated Bibliography"

This article went above and beyond a simple "how to" document regarding annotated bibliographies.  It followed all of the guidelines set forth by Barzun and executed them well.  It had a clear subject, which Knott defined early on, gave examples of effective annotation and non-effective annotations, and provided questions and statements to enhance critical thinking.  Every aspect of the annotation was covered in a helpful way that will help me think for myself.  I also appreciated how Knott understands the variable purposes of an annotated bibliography and adapted the feedback accordingly because often times authors explain one singular purpose for a subject and leave the rest up to the reader.  We as readers had a sense of closure which is critical in any literary material but especially a research document, again as outlined by Barzun.  I look forward to using this as a guide for the semester!

Reacting to U of Toldeo, "Writing an Annotated Bibliography"

This was another helpful article regarding annotated bibliographies.  If forced to decide which article, Knott vs. U of Toledo, was more helpful I would choose Knott because of her meticulous array of critical thinking tools.  This article doesn't go into the same amount of detail but what is does quite well is provide examples.  There are two annotations (which didn't strike me as being well written, but that's beside the point) that were highlighted and labeled with what each phrase functioned as in the annotation as a whole.  This was a very clear explanation and kind of showed readers what an ideal annotation is.  This is very helpful but in a different way, so the two articles will work very well together.

Overall all three of these articles combine to help readers develop a firm understanding of annotated bibliographies, their purposes, and how to go about writing one.  Each source provides different methods for thinking.

Quoted from Barzun:

"They illustrate the general truth that reading, writing, and thinking are the three activities of research."

This statement perfectly summarizes this assignment.  We must read, write, and think in order to be successful researchers!