Friday, September 16, 2016

Blog Post 3

Reacting to Wagstaff,
     Wagstaff wrote out some very informative history and details and what exactly periodicals are.  Essentially, they are very specifically designed for certain audiences.  as an example I receive the Music Educator's journal from NAfME monthly because of my membership.  The journal is wonderful to read through because of the detail into which it goes regarding trends in the classroom, new tools that are coming around, or even national movements in education, such as the abolishment of No Child Left Behind.  My favorite line in the reading is:

     "While books may mark the milestones of a particular subject, periodicals chart the small steps, false trails, and dead ends that are travelled along the way, and give diversion, enjoyment, and information."

     Essentially, periodicals are necessary for enthusiasts of any hobby, genre, or profession to maintain adequacy within the field.  Periodicals may not be monuments of research, but they are certainly accurate play by play records to help us stay in tune with our peers.

Reacting to Weir,
     Weird poses some interesting points regarding how we read articles and I agree with many of them.  We can't treat these the same way we would read Harry Potter or any similar book; we'd miss the point entirely.  Skim them, make notes in the margins, apply it to something you know well to get meaning out of what the author suggests.  I feel like we've covered many of these points in previous classes and readings.  However, something that the article lacks to describe is at what point do we bridge the gap between undergraduate and professional reading?  He describes tactics to have new undergraduates survive, and details that upperclassmen need to be challenged more, but at what point do we fully engross ourselves in the article?  The author's credibility?  Delving into where they found their information?  Perhaps we should be doing that right here right now!  This would be interesting to talk about in class.

Western Libraries,
     This was a cute video about how to read scholarly articles.  It wasn't my favorite resource we've looked at because it didn't provide much new information, rather it just repeated much of what Weir stated in his writing and discussions we've had in class.  Also, I didn't particularly care for the video, it was overly cheesy (a wedding simulating committing to an article??).  I suppose it helped engage the audience a bit more actively so it did its job.  The only new piece of information I found helpful was to reread the article after the original scan and reading to cement your understanding.  However in a world with not nearly enough time I don't know how many people will actually see this process all the way through.

Reacting to Antelman:
     The funny thing about this article was that I utilized the tips that the other articles suggested to get through it.  I definitely skimmed this article, starting with the abstract, conclusion, and then the results and discussion paragraphs as well, followed my a glance over the entire article.  The text of the document certainly did not call out to me and I did not want to marry it (and I made fun of that relationship...).  That being said, I thought the article was well research, VERY detailed, and posed an almost uncreative conclusion.  To me it would be very logical that articles that are free to access would have more of an impact on research through citation.  Looking at it from my perspective as an educator, I am going to lose access to many databases once I graduate from IC and once a public school teacher I may or may not have the same resources available.  If not, I am going to have to resort to open access articles to research anything unless I want to purchase subscriptions myself (I don't).  However logical it may seem though Antelman provides solid research on the subject and also considers how this trend may affect the behaviors of all parties involved, from authors to readers to publishers.

Reacting to Beall:
   This article was very interesting and made me feel bad for being so cold when reading the Antelman.  Until reading what Beall had to say I didn't even consider that "bad guys" could infiltrate the scholastic world.  It's always disappointing when you figure out something like that.  You'd think that something like educational and professional writing would be safe.  Anyway, Beall poses alarming arguments again Open Access articles, where those who are doing the writing are the ones who suffer.  Is there some sort of published list of qualified publishers?  How often do legitimate publisher's develop?  If the number is low is stands to reason that a list of well-known publishers would suffice but since the scam rate is so high I don't know how accurate my assumption is.

Reacting to Kolata:
     Another article that paints open access articles in a bad light, this one provides more examples and I find to be more helpful in understanding what can happen to legitimate people.  I enjoyed how this article actually mentioned Beall and his list (as I had wished for) of journals that were not to be trusted.  I also particularly enjoyed how Kolata referred to the journals as spam accounts, especially with certain authors wanting to be removed from websites and such.
     Kolata and Beall definitely made me reconsider my opinion on open access articles. It may be more convenient for me but if it hurts the authors so much there will eventually be a decline in published free articles anyway.  Would it be better if most authors stuck to legitimate publishers?  Maybe there could be open access versions for readers to look at but the full articles are only available through subscription articles.  Just a thought.

1 comment:

  1. I find it funny how we both agree on everything said about these articles. As I was reading your reactions to these articles I found myself understand more to the last two articles and their arguments on open-access. I agree with you that authors should stick to legitimate publishers, even though it will suck not being able to read their work it is better for the author.

    ReplyDelete