Friday, September 30, 2016

Blog Post 4

Reacting to Sampsel:
     This was a fair and straightforward read about plagiarism.  Sampsel goes into the basic definition and explains some real world applications, i.e. possible scenarios and punishments, but then gives many excellent examples of what plagiarism could look like.  He gives readers a look into exactly what deliberate, minor, and accidental plagiarism could look like by providing the original text as well as a plagiarized use of it but is most helpful by also providing readers with an authentic use of the material that includes a citation.  I think this would be particularly helpful for new students and scholars to get a handle on the dangers of plagiarism.  What Sampsel provides can often look like paraphrasing to an uneducated student.

Reacting to Sands:
     I LOVED this.  It spoke to my soul.  Plagiarism is indeed wrong and I haven't met anyone who questions that subject, but the area greys once we get into accidental plagiarism.  An example from my own history: in undergrad I wrote a paper on Beethoven and two of his piano sonatas, comparing and contrasting their emotions with the period of his life they were written in.  I believe I was focusing on the Tempest Sonata and I made the connection that this was written very close to when the Heilegenstadt Testament was written, so the emotion within the music was so dramatic because he realized he was losing his hearing.  I thought I was a genius for thinking of that.  I had submitted it in a rough draft and was looking into more sources for the final draft and found that same conclusion by an author many years prior.  I was very upset because it truly was my own idea but I ended up citing the other author to avoid plagiarism.
     In today's world, as Sands stated, information exchanges hands incredibly quickly and we can access pools of facts and ideas at the touch of a smartphone.  So much has been written, it seems like the odds are that someone has already written about it unless the research topic is brand new.  While my professor didn't "catch" my mistake, I don't feel like accidental plagiarism should be harshly punished.  I should have been more thorough in my research, but I did not blatantly steal the idea.
     The issue of foreign students has come up twice now and with the second iteration I realize its importance.  These students have a real struggle juggling two cultures.  I don't think they should be excused and be allowed to write as they see fit, but they should be made thoroughly aware of how this country cites its sources and they should adapt accordingly.  Professors should certainly spend time and educate them on that subject.

Reacting to Gladstone:
   This final reading brought up many interesting points.  Once I had gotten a glimpse of what the article would be about, I expected to react to it like I had with the Open Access article bad guys.  Honestly I'm not sure how I feel about this yet, it's almost as if Goldsmith is allowing students to take a shortcut.  Almost as if he is saying "You guys are going to plagiarize anyway, I might as well teach you how to do it well."
   I understand what his point is, and it is similar to what I was talking about in the Sands: plagiarism is everywhere.  In music we have sampling, and art is all about taking images and morphing them, so why is literature so far behind?  It's a weird thing to talk about because I could say that literature is considered intellectual property and can't be considered as "free" as music is (sometimes- sampling is definitely a grey area), but then that is arguing that music isn't intellectual property when it is.  Therefore I think it is interesting to say that the various types of literature have varying levels of "plagiaristic potential."  Poems are very free, as Goldsmith stated.  Novel plots are protected, as shown in the story told by Sands.  Shouldn't scholastic writing be protected as well?  Well-researched articles and papers should not be able to be copy and pasted, the property should be protected for the author's sake.  I enjoyed this writing, it brought up interesting arguments.  I look forward to discussing it in class.

4 comments:

  1. With regards to foreign students, I agree that the cultural differences do not account as a valid excuse for plagiarism. Nearly all syllabuses/syllabi which I have seen directly address plagiarism. Let's say I went to a German university and there is some scholarly norm held there that is not upheld in America. If there are warnings about this code of conduct like there are in our courses regarding plagiarism, then I would expect to be held to the same standards and accept consequences as fit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Funnily enough, I had almost the same exact reaction in my blog in regards to the defence of plagiarism transcript. It actually slightly infuriated me but I don't think I totally was understanding his point. I also loved the Sands reading. I think there is always such a tiny, fine line between paraphrasing plagiarizing, and yes it's often unintentional. Some things I am still gray on as well - if you have a topic that you can back up with your own facts as well as opinions in your own way, but happen to have a conclusion as someone else, is it still valid? There's so much to keep track of here in the writers' world! I think that even though it's a lot easier to plagiarize with the copy and paste function of computers, I also think there are lots of of good preventative measures in place to fight it, like sites such as turnitin.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have this fear every time I turn in a big paper that somehow every conclusion I actually did come to on my own is already in some other published work. So to that end, reading your story about how it ACTUALLY happened to you, I don't think that fear is so irrational anymore.
    The Sands reading also spoke to me. In my blog there is quite a large section where I am rambling about the idea of double standards when it comes to the consequences/lack thereof for plagiarism.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think what we should keep in mind about Goldsmith's stance is that he's made a career out of collaging stuff, and being straightforward about it: his skill is not to create stuff, but rather to create interesting combinations of existing things, which I think it's OK if you credit sources of (poetic, visual, musical) material (like Beethoven did by appropriately naming his "Diabelli" variations), but not just using stuff and saying "there! I put this together! =D" (smiley face added for dramatic purposes).

    As a student coming from another culture at some point, I agree with you: understanding the issue should NOT be an excuse to plagiarism (as James wrote), but certainly, knowing that it is a thing helps in how to tackle it.

    Great post, Nik!

    ReplyDelete