Reacting to Slonimsky:
I will admit to having shuddered a bit when I saw we had to read another definition, but this one by Slominsky was riddled with humor and almost an element of sass. The definition was clear after a short introduction and then it went on to elaborate on examples and various urtext scenarios. I particularly enjoyed the varied composer reactions to individuals fixing their mistakes.
Reacting to Haskell (Grove Music Online):
This was a very enlightening recount of how musical passions start and evolve over time. Aside from my undergrad music course I have very little experience with early music and this article was well written and informative on not only what was is considered "early music" but how it grew in importance as well. It was very interesting to see the trends across the years. The original movement was started by royals almost "fighting" modern music by bringing back the old classics (sounds familiar...). But how certain composer's rose in importance and then even (a more modern trend) is to perform them on accurate instrument. I thought it was amazing that German instrument makers began to churn out older styled instruments for this reason. My other favorite point was how the early music trend changed with the rest of history and how certain countries became more involved in it as time went on (post WWII U.S. was very different from the U.S. in the 1800s).
Reacting to Taruskin:
Taruskin writes a very detailed and revealing article about the presence of early music in our society and raises many questions that don't have answers. The way in which early music is performed and how it should be performed have created quite the controversy in today's world. By attempting to keep music as accurate and "authentic" to the time in which it was created are we limiting ourselves and our creativity? Most assuredly, but do we owe it to the composers to maintain their art (I like how Taruskin uses "curator" to describe this act)? Or can we take creative liberty and adapt music of old to the current time? I do not have an answer, and don't know if we need to have one. I think there are enough people of both mindsets to coexist and maintain the music of old and modernize it as well that we don't have to choose. It almost seems like giving up but there is value to both scenarios. We can argue about solo repertoire interpretations as well (and we have mentioned it in class). I think there is room for both in this world; if we limit ourselves to either side of the spectrum too much then we may run the risk of extinguishing the art all together.
Reacting to Kozinn:
To me this article was a more approachable version of Taruskin. Kozinn even mentions the article written by the other author as groundbreaking, which it was, but I got more out of this writing because the focus seemed to be more on how people have come to expect to hear music and how modern composers, who have a say in how their music is interpreted today, are as ambiguous as the composers who cannot effect their music today. I am not surprised though, as music is a fluid art form and is never really done. Currently my brass quintet is working on a premiere for a student composer, and the free and open-mindedness of him is refreshing and easy to work with. As Kozinn mentioned early on, the term "historically-informed" is more appropriate for modern early music than authentic because how are we supposed to know? In my 20th century theory class in undergrad we talked about this a lot. How important is it to create "the truth" in early music? How can we even know, and how important is it? We had no distinct answer for this and I think that was the point.
No comments:
Post a Comment